Million Media

See Things Differently

BPI Letter Shows How Much Trouble The Music Industry Is In…

This open letter from Geoff Taylor demonstrates the almost irreversible problem faced by the Record Industry.

Geoff Taylor is Chairman of the BPI, who if you didn’t know, are the trade body who represent the Major record labels (officially, they’re meant to represent all labels but that’s only a technicality). His argument against Bill Thompson is so laughable and full of holes that it takes a couple of re-reads to fully appreciate it.

For the BPI to accuse anyone of having ‘dated views’ defies belief, especially when those ‘dated views’ are simply being supportive of new models of digital distribution. The fact P2P services are not licensed is viewed by the BPI as ‘Digital Utopianism’ rather than as ‘Commercial Suicide’ by the members who refuse to work with them.

Taylor then goes on the cite services such as EMusic, Napster, and We7 as fine examples of new licensed digital services. EMusic can’t get licenses from the Majors who will not work with MP3. Napster have been forced in to using consumer-unfriendly WMA for years at the insistence of the Majors. Warners have just pulled out of saying their license rate is ‘out of whack’ with companies like Imeem (who were being sued by Warners when they were forced in to agreeing a non-commercial rate). And We7’s free model is not licensed by Majors.

I don’t normally use this blog to criticise the BPI because it’s far too easy and there are sufficient number of other people doing it. But Taylor’s email, being such a public admittance of ignorance and short-sightedness, really has to be shot down as a piece of corporate propaganda bullshit that is holding back music distribution for both artists and fans.


About Neil

Neil Cartwright founded Million Media in 2006 with the aim to help people understand digital marketing and use it to their advantage. The vision hasn't changed but the technology has.

One comment on “BPI Letter Shows How Much Trouble The Music Industry Is In…

  1. Bill Thompson
    June 16, 2008

    thanks for the comprehensive demolition of the BPI’s ‘response’ to my piece – I’d hoped they’d use to opportunity to describe how they were moving forward to ensure that I don’t have to resort to BitTorrent to get shows or other networks to listen to stuff I might then want to buy, but clearly they don’t really care. Their loss.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on June 16, 2008 by in blogs and tagged , , , , .
%d bloggers like this: